BC Supreme Court strikes down assisted suicide law.

6 posts / 0 new
Last post
fuchsiasky's picture
Joined: 11/16/07
Posts: 955
BC Supreme Court strikes down assisted suicide law.

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/story/2012/06/15/bc-assisted-suicide-ruling.html

The BC Supreme Court has struck down the assisted suicde ban on the basis that it discriminates against the severely disabled.

In her ruling, Smith noted suicide itself is not illegal, and therefore the law against assisted suicide contravenes Section 15 of the charter, which guarantees equality, because it denies physically disabled people like Taylor the same rights as able-bodied people who can take their own lives, she ruled.

"The impact of that distinction is felt particularly acutely by persons such as Ms. Taylor, who are grievously and irremediably ill, physically disabled or soon to become so, mentally competent and who wish to have some control over their circumstances at the end of their lives," Smith writes.

"The distinction is discriminatory ? because it perpetuates disadvantage."

Smith also says the law deprives both people like Taylor and those who try to help them of the right to life and liberty guaranteed under Section 7 of the charter.

She argued the legislation could force a person to take their life sooner than they want to in order to kill themselves while still physically capable.

And Smith says the risk of incarceration denies the right of freedom to relatives who assist by taking their loved ones to jurisdictions where physician-assisted suicide is legal.

...

At the end of the decision, Smith also stipulates that her ruling only apply to "competent, fully informed, non-ambivalent adult persons who personally (not through a substituted decision-maker) request physician-assisted death, are free from coercion and undue influence and are not clinically depressed."

Do you agree with this ruling?

fuchsiasky's picture
Joined: 11/16/07
Posts: 955

I am very pleased to see this ruling. People should have the right to make the choice about the end of their own lives. In many cases those who are ill suffer so much that to deny them the right to die by their own choice is downright cruel, imo.

mom2robbie's picture
Joined: 01/20/07
Posts: 2541

"fuchsiasky" wrote:

I am very pleased to see this ruling. People should have the right to make the choice about the end of their own lives. In many cases those who are ill suffer so much that to deny them the right to die by their own choice is downright cruel, imo.

I agree. Right now I am waiting for my mom to finally pass on. She has been in pretty much a vegetative state for over 6 months. She has a DNR, I wish that we would have the chance to help her pass on.

ClairesMommy's picture
Joined: 08/15/06
Posts: 2299

I absolutely agree with the ruling and was very happy to read about this last week. I hope that this decision will not be appealed, but if it the decision is overturned and this goes (again) to the Supreme Court of Canada that the 20 or so years they've had to live with their last decision on the matter will have changed a few minds.

Spacers's picture
Joined: 12/29/03
Posts: 4100

ITA with it. I've never understood the opposition to assisted suicide. If someone truly wants to end their life, then who are we to stop them? Those of us who are able-bodied can hold a gun to our head or throw ourselves off a bridge, but those ways of dying are pretty traumatic to those have to witness the action or deal with the cleanup. And, as the BCSC stated, the disabled have little or no options. It's far better for everyone involved IMHO to be able to leave this life in a decent & respectful way.

ClairesMommy's picture
Joined: 08/15/06
Posts: 2299

"Spacers" wrote:

ITA with it. I've never understood the opposition to assisted suicide. If someone truly wants to end their life, then who are we to stop them? Those of us who are able-bodied can hold a gun to our head or throw ourselves off a bridge, but those ways of dying are pretty traumatic to those have to witness the action or deal with the cleanup. And, as the BCSC stated, the disabled have little or no options. It's far better for everyone involved IMHO to be able to leave this life in a decent & respectful way.

Agree. Pets often die with more dignity than people do.