So I have a good friend who's mother is dying of cancer. (I posted one other debate about her) She wants her to live as long as humanly possible. She has had 3 different doctors tell her she will die, it is just a matter of when.
Debate question. Once you get to that point, would you just stop treatment and have as much possible in the time remaining. Or, would you do every treatment possible to postpone death as long as possible.
One thing she said to me was that even if it made her live one extra day, it would be worth it. I want to be the best support possible, so help me understand that line of thinking.
Whether we have cancer or not, we're all going to die, it's just a matter of when.
I wouldn't want to live in needless pain. I don't want anyone I love to live in needless pain. Treatment should do one of two things: fix the problem, or ammeliorate the symptoms to make life better. IMHO if there is no point to treatment, there is no point to continuing it; if the treatment can't cure the mother, and isn't making her life better, and she wants it to stop, then it should stop even if it ends her life. And if the pain can't be managed in a reasonable way, I would choose, every time, to let that person go as quickly & painlessly as possible. Let them die with dignity. Let them pump themselves full of morphine and be deliriously happy for a few days until their body gives out. Sadly, I've been in the sad position of having to do just that and I can't imagine choosing anything else.
I've said it before, I'll say it again: your friend is wrong. If her mother is tired of fighting and is ready to die, then she needs to get herself some counseling to help her accept that fact. You mentioned the last time that the daughter seemed to be trying to force the mother to accept treatment the mother didn't want. I hope the mother has gotten others involved who will help her make her own decisions. If not, I strongly encourage you to help. (((((HUGS))))) I'm so sorry you're in this position. Wishing you all peace.
70% of the U.S. population now lives in a state where same-sex marriage is legal. At 36 and counting!
On your specific example, I think it's time for her to let her mom go It's hard and it's sad but it's a wonderful thing to give her an easy way to go.
This is a very difficult situation. My brother-in-law has colon cancer and has been fighting it for about 3 years now. They have exhausted all the known chemo options and it keeps coming back. They have discontinued chemo and he has an appointment with the Mayo clinic next week to see if they have any experimental treatments they can try. He still wants to fight it if he can, he is only 58 years old and he and my sister have just adopted their one year old granddaughter. But at some point if you have exhausted all the options you have to accept the inevitable. I think if it was me I would fight it as long as possible because I would want to spend every minute I can with my kids/grandkids. A lot of it depends on the side affects of the treatment, if the treatment makes you sick and takes away some of the enjoyment of the time you could be spending with your family it might not be worth it if it is not going to give you much more time anyway. And if you keep having surgery to remove tumors at some point it just isn't worth going through the pain of surgery if the tumors are going to come back. I don't think there is ever a cut and dry answer because each case would be so different.
A good friend of mine's husband passed away just a couple months ago from a brain tumor. They cut it out once and it just grew right back. At that point I don't think I would have the surgery again, and that is what they chose to do also. It was very hard for her to watch him go, but at some point you know that is the best thing, and that is the option he chose.
Mom to Lee, Jake, Brandon, Rocco
Stepmom to Ryan, Regan, Braden, Baley
Granddaughters Kylie 10/18/2010 & Aleya 4/22/2013
I never consider a difference of opinion in politics, in religion, in philosopy, as a cause for withdrawing from a friend. --Thomas Jefferson
I'm a big advocate for end-of-life choices. The choices of the terminally ill, that is. We're more humane to our pets than we are to each other.
If I was at that point - I wouldn't go through pointless treatment just for one more pain-filled day. Stop the treatment, give me a bit of pain medication and let me go when I'm ready, surrounded by my loved ones at home. Better yet, let me decide when I die. Let me leave the world with some dignity, when I'm ready, on my terms.
Anybody else see the euthanasia debate coming?
It isn't the daughter choice. It is her mom's. If mom feels enough is enough, than her daughter needs to find a way to come to terms with that.
-Alissa, mom to Tristan (5) and Reid (the baby!)
Got an opinion? We've got a board! Come join us for some lively debate on the Face Off! Debate Arena board.
Unfortunately I am facing all of this right now. My mother has incurable cancer. It's very hard to write this without crying no matter how many times I do it.
Right now my mom is 100% focused on treatment and getting better. She doesn't care what the doctors tell her; she says she is going to survive this. But the doctors have told us (as her kids she has given us permission to speak to her doctor without her) that it is aggressive and spreading.
Our job, as we see it AND as the doctor tells us, is to support my mom however she needs it most. Right now she wants to focus on treatment and the positive so we are supporting that and all the efforts she makes. Unless a miracle happens, at some point she will shift and need a very different type of support, and we will all change with her. It's about the patient, really. If I thought my mom had a chance at a better quality of life and she wasn't taking it, I'd pressure her, but when the time comes that she has tried everything and it's over, I'll support whatever she wants to do.
In the meantime you make the most of what you have. My mom lives far away from all of us, so the four of us kids (in our 40s!) all take turns calling her so she gets a call every day, and we are taking turns visiting as well. I have been to see her twice and I'm planning another visit in November. I brought the kids over the summer so they could spend time with her while she was still relatively healthy (but of course dealing with chemo). It's a full day's travel each way but we all do what we can.
I don't understand wanting someone you love to suffer. I understand denying the suffering because you want them to live, though. It's primal. I want my mom around too. But I have to put her first. Sometimes it's gut-wrenching when she talks about how her upcoming surgery will cure her, because I know that's not the case, but I tell her with all the honesty in my soul that I hope she is right and I love her.
The chemo is brutal, though. The last round was awful. She's getting a break from it for a while and I am grateful.
Laurie, mom to:
Nathaniel ( 11 ) and Juliet ( 7 )
Baking Adventures In A Messy Kitchen (blog)