If she was told to do it then I think it was wrong. But if she chose to do it herself then I think it was a personal decision.
Is it possible that she was also seeking the surgery to improve her vision? My cousin who was adopted from China has had the same surgery because her peripheral vision was being hindered.
Molly, Morgan, Mia and Carson
It wasn't her vision. It was her choice as in she wasn't forced to do it but she was told that she wouldn't get hired if she looked too Chinese, and that her natural eyes made her look disinterested.
I don't fault her for being young and ambitious and wanting to succeed but I fault the racists who said she wouldn't work without it (or wouldn't hire her) and our creepy society for such a racist, narrow view of tv-friendly looks. I hope we're less like that now, and that there aren't Asian women feeling like they have to do this to succeed anymore.
And I would say that she *was* in a powerful position. Even though the station manager wasn't the one who told her to have eye surgery, his saying she wouldn't be on the anchor desk because she's Chinese is outright racism -- and she says that on the show! She didn't do that, nor did she pursue jobs at other stations, or in other cities, or seek out a different agent. Instead, she stayed at that station for a year and developed a complex about herself that led her to decide that eye surgery was the best decision. Racism is illegal, and she could have (should have?) filed a discrimination complaint against that employer, which may have opened the door without her feeling she needed to resort to surgery.
But what it comes down to, is that she did what she thought she should do for her career, and she did not do anything about the racism that made her feel that way. I'm glad the station has apologized & pointed out that this would never happen today. We've made a lot of progress against racism since 1995.
70% of the U.S. population now lives in a state where same-sex marriage is legal. At 36 and counting!
This is a weird thing to nitpick IMO....the issue was the pressure put on her to be 'less asian' and conform to some sort of western standard of feminine beauty.
She was not in a powerful position...she had a ton to lose if she decided to do that. It would have been commendable for her to pursue that...but lets not pretend there was no great risk to her life goals and ambitions by going this route and alienating herself from the industry. Victims of racism are NOT in a powerful position. They have to sacrifice the most if they want to contribute to the fight against racism. It irks me that you are trying to even argue this.And I would say that she *was* in a powerful position. Even though the station manager wasn't the one who told her to have eye surgery, his saying she wouldn't be on the anchor desk because she's Chinese is outright racism -- and she says that on the show! She didn't do that, nor did she pursue jobs at other stations, or in other cities, or seek out a different agent. Instead, she stayed at that station for a year and developed a complex about herself that led her to decide that eye surgery was the best decision. Racism is illegal, and she could have (should have?) filed a discrimination complaint against that employer, which may have opened the door without her feeling she needed to resort to surgery.
Last edited by KimPossible; 09-17-2013 at 10:30 PM.
I agree with Kim.
She was at the beginning of her career, trying to get on-air....this is not a position of power. Discrimination is hard to prove, harder back then, and complaints like that can make you unhire-able. I think it's a sad story all around.
It is unfortunate that this happens, but I think it is common even today. Maybe not that they would boldly say it was because of her race, but people on TV are expected to look a certain way if they want to keep their jobs. Whether that means plastic surgery, a diet so drastic you are borderline anorexic, liposuction or whatever. It is a very high pressure industry with heavy focus on looks.
Well maybe not better, just that the groups of people who fall victim to these problems are different. I think South Asians have more problems than Eastern Asians these days. Take the Miss America thing for example.
Last edited by KimPossible; 09-18-2013 at 10:05 AM.
I watch big brother.. so yes I did notice.. it was a dramatic difference in her nose.. I didn't notice the eye difference.. I did notice her face was more angular and less round. I am not sure why she did it.. she does have the money to do it.. and it is keeping someone employed.. I guess I shouldn't complain. But how far is ok and what line we draw at too much varies from person to person. I would like to get liposuction myself.. and maybe a boob job... WHY? to feel more comfortable in our society. It is all controlled by society I think.. unless we are talking a medical issue.. ie soo overweight that your knees and feet are hurting to much.. or breast reduction because of back pain.. Etc etc. or reconstructive after a bad accident to be able to function. (however some reconstructive surgery is also controlled by societal views of "normal" and "beautiful". Also just because something is influenced even heavily by societal norms and you do it doesn't make your doing it wrong/sinful etc.. It is just important I think to understand how where we live and who we associate with has a baring on what we do.
DH-Aug 30th 1997 Josiah - 6/3/02 Isaac 7/31/03
?? (yes i'm putting words in your mouth so i expect you to say thats not what you meant, but i'm looking for the alternative explanation to what your point actually is)
ETA: i just watched a video (because the link was on the front page of msn) and she has never had any plastic surgery aside from her eyes
Last edited by KimPossible; 09-18-2013 at 11:11 AM.