After a *lot* of Google searches and reading reviews I have finally chosen a diaperbag! It is from The Bumble Collection, is highly rated, and (even better) is on sale!
I ordered directly from their website. I've seen this bag featured on other sites for $120 (ugh!). Right now they have many of their products in certain prints on a summer sale. This includes shopping cart covers for $32.99 (retail $62.99) in select prints. If any of your are babysteals.com addicts like I am, the steal yesterday was the discontinued Natalie tote with matching paci case for around $65. I thought that the Natalie might be too big for my use and wasn't interested in the paci case so I went to their website and found a slightly smaller bag for less $$$!
PS- BS still has some Natalie/paci case that didn't sell out. They will hit archives tomorrow I think.