Here's my play with my typical adjustments. I did a gradient map layer.
Then added a levels layer and slid the right RGB slider to the bottom of the histogram. Next I moved the middle slider a little bit to the right to add some contrast to the darks. His hair got a little too dark with that, so I masked the hair back in.
Then I added a brightness/contrast layer. Here are those adjustments.
And the result.
How does that look to you? I don't think anything is blown. I didn't check the numbers (and rarely do, since they're just for my own use).
Steph, that looks very good. I can see that part of the issue is that you simply add more contrast. I used to do that, but got scared away from it when I was repeatedly being told I'd clipped my blacks or blown my highlights. But if I look at our two images in GIMP, I can see from the Threshold info that our highlights are pretty similar, but the contrast between the highlights and the blacks is less.
I didn't really mean this to be a thread just about my conversion issues, mind you, because I would really like to hear some discussion about great black-and-white photos in general, and what makes them so. I know about the light, and I guess I'm seeing from Steph's conversion of my image that part of it is related to contrast as well. Anything else?
Married Anthony April 2, 2005
Nora born Feb. 14th, 2007
Micah born Jan. 20, 2009
Whenever I look at a B&W, I like to see the way the light areas and shadows work together to form shapes. That's why directional lighting works so well in conversions; the shadows create a nice 3-D effect that flat lighting can't.
I also love amped-up contrast. A good B&W has white whites and black blacks, as previously stated.
I know my siggy isn't a good B&W; it's flashy and bright and some flash areas are completely blown, but I think it kind of adds to the chaotic snapshot photojournalistic look I was going for.
Oh, and I once saw a gorgeous B&W portrait of a musician where the photographer left in some grain (or maybe added some; I don't really know), and it looked fantastic. So I guess grain adds grit and grunge.
plus DH Reeve, DS Sean, DS Luke, and DD Eve
and furbaby Reese's Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup "Buttercup"
My 365 Photography Project
Although I don't know a whole lot about the technical details, I have made several "successful" b&ws in the past couple years (based on feedback here) and aside from good sooc exposure, I find when I'm converting, the contrast is a major key, often taking the highlights/darks up a lot more than you would if it was staying in color.
Last edited by Amy_&_Eva; 01-29-2013 at 02:27 PM.
~*~ my photography site ~*~
I'm not technical when I convert. I just adjust things until I like them. I usually use a preset and then adjust it to my liking for the particular shot. I do, however, try to only convert to b&w when the lighting is right. I'm so in love with b&w, that I end up deleting a lot of photos that don't work well in b&w....oops. It's a bad habit and I'm trying to stop!